When you first hear about Variable Universal Life (VUL) insurance, it might sound like the best of both worlds—life insurance protection plus the potential for investment growth. And while it can be a powerful tool for wealth building, there’s a hidden danger that most people don’t fully understand until it’s too late:

The biggest risk with VUL insurance is market volatility reducing your cash value—sometimes to the point where your policy lapses.

Let’s unpack that risk in a way that’s clear, personal, and crucial for anyone evaluating whether VUL insurance is the right fit for their financial goals.

The Illusion of “Set and Forget”

When you buy a VUL policy, it’s easy to fall into a false sense of security. You’re paying your premiums, you’ve chosen your investment funds, and the projections your agent showed you make everything look rosy. Over time, you expect to see your policy’s cash value grow steadily, and that growth will help pay for future insurance costs.

But here’s the truth:

Those projections are based on assumptions—not guarantees. If the market performs poorly or if your investments don’t deliver as expected, your cash value can decline. And when that happens, your policy may not be able to sustain itself.

How Market Volatility Puts Your Policy at Risk

Your VUL policy relies on investments—usually in mutual funds, equities, or bond funds—called sub-accounts. These aren’t fixed returns. They go up and down depending on market conditions.

When the market drops, the value of those sub-accounts drops, too. Meanwhile, the cost of insurance continues to rise as you get older. That combination can be devastating to your policy’s performance.

Here’s a scenario that happens more often than you’d think:

• A 45-year-old policyholder has been paying regular premiums for 10 years.
• The market crashes (think 2008 or 2020) and their policy’s fund value drops by 30%.
• There’s now not enough cash value to cover the increasing cost of insurance.
• If they don’t add more premiums to make up for the shortfall, the policy lapses.

And when a policy lapses, you lose the insurance protection. Worse, if your cash value was higher than what you paid in premiums, the IRS (or your country’s tax authority) may tax the gain—even though you didn’t receive the full value.

Why This Risk Feels Personal

Many policyholders don’t discover the danger until they receive a notice in the mail saying their policy is about to lapse. And by then, rebuilding it can be very expensive—or impossible if their health has changed.

I’ve personally spoken to a friend who had to make an emergency decision in his late 50s: either inject thousands of pesos into his VUL to keep it from lapsing, or let it go and lose over 15 years of payments. He chose to save the policy, but it derailed his retirement plans.

That’s why it’s so important to understand the risks from the beginning—not just the potential rewards.

Can You Prevent Policy Lapse Due to Market Volatility?

Yes, but it requires active participation. VUL insurance isn’t a “set it and forget it” product. Here are a few ways to manage the risk:

1. Monitor Your Policy Regularly

Review your policy statements at least once or twice a year. Are your fund values holding up? Is your cash value growing? Knowing your policy’s health status helps you act before a lapse risk sneaks up.

2. Diversify Your Investments

Don’t put everything in high-risk equity funds. If your policy offers balanced or bond sub-accounts, consider using them to stabilize your portfolio, especially as you age.

3. Adjust Premium Payments

If your cash value is falling, increase your premium (if your budget allows). A temporary bump in payments can protect your policy during rough markets.

4. Rebalance During Good Years

When your policy performs well, consider reallocating gains into more conservative funds. Lock in those gains before the next downturn.

5. Consider a Policy Review

Work with your financial advisor or insurance agent to run updated projections based on current fund performance and your age. It can help you spot risks early.

Not All Policies Are Created Equal

It’s essential to note that terms, fund choices, fee structures, and risk exposure vary between insurance companies, between countries, and even between products offered by the same insurer.

Some policies come with built-in safeguards like guaranteed minimum death benefits or automatic rebalancing options. Others place all the investment risk squarely on your shoulders.

Disclosure: Always read the fine print of your specific policy. What applies in the Philippines may not apply in the U.S., the U.K., Canada, or Australia. Even VUL policies from the same insurer can behave very differently depending on their structure.

Final Thoughts: Knowledge Is Your Best Insurance

VUL insurance offers a lot of potential benefits, but the biggest risk is letting market volatility silently erode your policy’s foundation.

Cash value is not guaranteed. Fund performance can go south. And when that happens, your policy might not be able to support the rising cost of insurance. That’s the reality—and the risk—you need to accept and actively manage.

If you’re considering VUL, do so with eyes wide open. Ask questions. Request detailed policy projections. Understand your fund options. And most importantly, commit to reviewing your policy regularly.

It’s your money, your protection, and your future. Make sure your VUL works for you—not against you.

[OK]